I can't argue with you about Club H aesthetics, they did a nice job. But I found that there are some major differences well worth considering.
For one thing, you are locked into a yearly contract as compared to NYSC's month to month. And is it really worth saving $60.00 per year by paying the annual membership "up-front."
Another NYSC plus is that you can use anyone of their "other" gyms in NY, CT, and PA. I like the fact that I can go to another gym. Some of my friends live in Hoboken and work in Manhattan. The option to use another NYSC makes the commitment to "keeping to a workout routine" both convenient and that much easier.
BTW... Most, if not all, of the NYSC facilities are clean, aesthetically pleasing, and well equipped. Although the Hoboken NYSC is in the basement, there is an additional NYSC being built at 14th and Park. NYSC is currently building a second gym at 14th and Park in Hoboken. Thats TWO NYSC gyms in Hoboken....
Think twice before you lock yourself into a yearly contract with any gym.